Sunday 18 November 2018

Some further thoughts about Upton Sinclair’s proposition

The American novelist Upton Sinclair had this to say about the difficulty in getting through to people:

"It is difficult to get a man to understand something, when his salary depends upon his not understanding it!"

The previous article expanded on this statement and listed some external factors that might be involved in addition to someone’s salary.

It is not just about employees and possible losses in the outer world: Upton Sinclair’s proposition can be applied to the inner world of many people when psychological factors are involved.

There may also be some unseen influences at work in the form of good and evil forces.

Some psychological factors
Psychological defence mechanisms may be at work in many cases where people just don’t or won’t get or accept an inconvenient, unwelcome truth. For example, we may try very hard but unsuccessfully to get through to someone that they need to take responsibility for their actions.


We need to learn that they simply cannot afford to understand; we need to think about the reasons for their determination not to learn or understand something in terms of what might be at stake for them; we need to think of the implications if they do come to understand and accept something.

We need to understand that even if we are trying to get ideas across to someone for their benefit and not ours, we may make matters much worse.

They may feel that we are trying to force bitter pills on them; they may feel that their lifelines are being threatened. They may avoid or even attack us. We may be playing with fire.

What else might be at stake?
Understanding and accepting something may mean the loss not only of someone’s salary and peace of mind, but in extreme cases of their sanity. Even their life may be at risk.

Their world view and philosophy of life may collapse like a house of cards. They may lose their ability to function. They may lose all hope for the future and even their reason for living.

Huge amounts of negative emotions may be unleashed and great psychological pain may be involved.

Ignorance really is bliss in many cases. The truth can devastate and destroy.

Understanding and unseen influences
I get the idea that behind and below the psychological factors there are two subtle forces at work, one good and one evil.

These forces both conceal and reveal the truth. Evil acts to sabotage people’s lives for its own benefit, the opposite force acts for the benefit of the person involved.

The first subtle influence may prevent its victims from realising things until it is too late, or even at all. It may blind someone for many years then suddenly pull the rug out from under them just to feast on the resulting negative emotion. For example, it may force someone to realise that they have wasted their life when it is too late to do anything about it.

The other force may protect people who just cannot deal with reality. It may also drip-feed people who will benefit in the long term by facing up to the truth, giving them only what they can cope with at the time.

Dealing with bureaucrats who won’t listen because their pay rises and promotion are at stake is bad enough; dealing with people whose refusal to understand is because metaphysical factors are involved is much worse.

It is even more important in these cases to be aware of what we are up against.

Before trying to knock a brick wall down, we need to understand why it was built in the first place.

Two opposing forces and a wall: